Godd character study and nicely composed. Spoilt by the blown out highlights.

I find the arm overexposed which is too bad because I love the feeling that you have captured, however, I am sure there will be advocates for the arm.

this makes me think of that 'dramatic portrait' theme. very nice.

Nicely handled. Very emotional and fitting. High marks.

This photo is very strong imho. the grain and the highlights work well. The composition is nice. I would like to see the blacks "blacker" especially in the lower left.