Featured in Night (Response #113)

Featured 631 Days Ago by peterchandra - - 6 comments

Photo © peterchandra (Peter Chandra) - www.peterchandra.com
Unauthorized reproduction not permitted.

User Comments

kadenajack said 631 days ago:

Interesting. I thought I'd already seen this one until I went back and looked to see that the same scene had been submitted, but obviously taken at a different time. http://weeklyshot.org/theme/night/response/6/

I think this works against the photographer ratings wise since I can compare the two photographs side by side, which is exactly what I'm doing. I don't even know if they were taken by the same person, but, I find response 6 to be the stronger of the two on three points.

1) Relevance - #6 appears to be taken later, and is thus more night-like for me.

2) Composition - #6 has a little more water, and thus reflections on the water and a little less sky, which in this case isn't adding much at the top of the frame.

3) Technique - #6 is slightly sharper overall. That's especially evident with the lights on the top of the leftmost sky scraper.

All that being said, I still like this image, but it's rare to get to judge two this similar side by side. Thanks for the exercise.

peterchandra said 631 days ago:

I'm so suprise that some one have Up load the same picture like Me before. May Be we at the same place but not the same time. Thanks

ChriZ said 631 days ago:

Now it's slanted the other way...
I like the one before better!
still nice though ;)

indahs said 631 days ago:

wow..great view!

AbsolutelyN said 631 days ago:

Great colours - I find the tilted horizon (or appartent tilted horizon) a bit distracting.

JLSpurling said 631 days ago:

nice cityscape. were you standing right next to Ashish when you took this photo? :-p

You could comment on this photo if you were logged in.